What Are the Safest Car Seats of 2023: RateWorks Guide

In 2020, a heart-wrenching toll of 607 young lives aged 12 and under were killed by motor vehicle accidents in the U.S. Devastatingly, over 63,000 more suffered injuries. Shockingly, 38% of these tragedies unfolded because children were not adequately secured. Amidst these somber statistics shines a beacon of hope:vigilant parents and guardians have the power to safeguard their precious ones.

And the direction is relatively clear—children under 4'9" tall or below eight years, differing by state, must ride in a car seat, strapped in, in the back seat. Join us as we unveil RateWorks recommended 10 Best Car Seats for 2023.

‍

Why do you need the best car seat?

Countless decisions mark the journey of parenthood, and one of those unending decisions ties to your children’s safety. Car seats and boosters are vital tools of protection for our little passengers, shielding them from the grim reality that car crashes rank among the leading causes of death for children aged one to 13. It's a weighty responsibility that highlights the importance of selecting and utilizing the right car seat every time your child embarks on a journey. 

While seat belts are ingeniously designed to cocoon adults during a collision, the same cannot be said for kids. Even at moderate speeds, crash forces can soar past 30 Gs—a force exceeding what fighter pilots endure. Seatbelts, engineered to grip adult hips, shoulders, and rib cages, are not tailored for the unique anatomy of children. Picture a five-year-old ensnared in an adult seat belt—the shoulder strap grazing the chin, knees unable to reach the floor without slouching, and the lap belt veering across the stomach. Such misalignment, especially during a crash, risks severe harm to delicate organs or even slipping under the belts.

This is where the RateWorks 10 Best Car Seats for 2023 can help. RateWorks, a respected auto refinance lender, is dedicated to fiscal well-being and the safety of everyone on the road. Our unbiased and reliable car seat reviews echo our commitment to safeguarding lives.

Car seat buying guide

Selecting the perfect car seat is an investment in your child's safety and comfort, which requires careful consideration. To navigate this crucial task, consider these vital factors when selecting the best car seats:

• Age-appropriate fit: Different stages of childhood demand distinct car seat types. Choose rear-facing options for infants, forward-facing ones for toddlers, and booster seats for older children.
• Safety features: Look for seats with a robust safety profile, including side-impact protection, energy-absorbing foam, and a sturdy harness system.
• Extended use: Opt for convertible car seats or all-in-one models that protect your child's growth throughout their young developmental phases.
• Installation ease: Ensure the car seat installation process is straightforward. Models with clear labels, straightforward instructions, and user-friendly attachment systems simplify the process.
• Compatibility and space: Assess whether the chosen car seat fits well within your vehicle's interior. Bulky designs clash with limited backseat space.
• Adjustability: A customizable car seat offers a snug fit as your child grows. Adjustable harness heights, recline positions, and headrests contribute to long-term comfort.
• Cleaning and maintenance: Children and mess often go hand-in-hand. And, kids can get carsick, too. Opt for car seats with removable, machine-washable covers for hassle-free cleanup.
• Reviews and ratings: Research independent reviews and safety ratings to gauge real-world performance and user satisfaction.
• Check expiration dates: Car seats have a lifespan due to material wear and evolving safety standards. Check the manufacturer's expiration date to ensure optimal performance. 

Navigating the sea of options becomes a breeze with these guiding principles. Prioritize safety, adaptability, and comfort, and remember that your choice of car seat plays a pivotal role in your child's road journey, ensuring every mile is traveled with utmost care and protection.

RateWorks methodology

At RateWorks, our car seat evaluations and rankings ensure that the safety and comfort of your child remain top of mind. We begin by extensively analyzing online reviews and aggregating crash test ratings from reputable and authoritative sources.  

Our expert team scrutinizes each car seat's performance in real-world scenarios, alongside adherence to rigorous safety standards such as side-impact protection, energy-absorbing features, installation ease, comfort elements, and overall design.

By integrating a holistic assessment approach, we provide unbiased and comprehensive insights into the top car seats, enabling you to make informed choices that prioritize your child's security on every road trip.

Top 10 car seat reviews

Selecting the right car seat transcends convenience; it's a powerful stride toward your child's safety on the road.According to Safe Kids Worldwide, these protective seats, designed just for kids, can reduce fatality risk by up to 71% when used correctly. Ensuring compliance with car-seat laws across all states, particularly for kids aged 5 and under, is a shared responsibility.

Our diligent research and assessment have yielded the ten Best Car Seats for 2023. Here's the crème de la crème:

1. Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1 ConvertibleCar Seat

The Graco 4Ever DLX 4-in-1 Convertible Car Seat is the summit of versatility and safety. With side-impact protection, an adjustable harness, plush padding, and a straightforward LATCH system, it earns a resounding five-star rating for its comprehensive features that ensure your child's comfort and protection from infancy through multiple stages of growth.

Safety: Side-impact protection, adjustable harness.

Installation: Straightforward LATCH system.

Comfort: Plush padding, multiple recline positions.

Performance: Versatility that grows with your child.

Pros:

• Versatility: The Graco 4Ever DLX is a true all-in-one solution, capable of accommodating infants in rear-facing mode, toddlers in forward-facing mode, and older children in high-back and backless booster modes. This versatility offers exceptional value and extended use for growing families.
• Safety features: The car seat comes with side-impact protection and a robust adjustable harness system, contributing to high safety. The steel-reinforced frame adds an extra layer of security in case of a collision.
• Ease of installation: The ClickTight installation system simplifies the installation process, making achieving a secure fit in the vehicle relatively easy. Clear labels and indicators guide users through proper installation, reducing the risk of errors. 

Cons:

• Bulky design: The Graco 4Ever DLX is relatively large and heavy, which might pose challenges in fitting it comfortably in smaller vehicles or for families with multiple car seats.
• Limited recline positions: Some users find that the recline positions, particularly in rear-facing mode, may not be as adjustable as they would prefer, potentially impacting comfort for infants and younger children.
• Price point: While the Graco 4Ever DLX offers outstanding versatility and safety, its premium features and functions are reflected in its price. It may be a more substantial investment compared to other car seats.

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

2. Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat

The Chicco KeyFit 30 Infant Car Seat is a trusted fortress of safety designed for newborns and infants. Boasting superior side-impact protection, easy installation with a leveling bubble-equipped base, and a cozy infant insert, it secures a five-star rating for its unmatched dedication to ensuring your little one's safety and comfort during those precious early journeys. 

Safety: Reputed for superior side-impact protection.

Installation: Easy-to-use base with leveling bubble.

Comfort: Thick padding, cozy infant insert.

Performance: Unmatched safety for newborns.

Pros:

• Outstanding safety: The Chicco KeyFit 30 is well-regarded for its excellent safety features, including superior side-impact protection and a secure, easy-to-install base with a leveling bubble. This focus on safety provides peace of mind for parents.
• User-friendly installation: The KeyFit 30's one-pull LATCH tightener and easy-to-read indicators simplify the installation process, reducing the chances of incorrect installation and ensuring a snug fit in a wide variety of vehicles.
• Comfort for newborns: The car seat has a plush infant insert designed for newborns and smaller infants. This feature enhances comfort and support during those crucial early months.

Cons:

• Weight and size: The Chicco KeyFit 30 is relatively heavier compared to some other infant car seats, which might make it less convenient for parents who frequently transfer it between car and stroller.
• Limited longevity: While the KeyFit 30 is exceptional for newborns and younger infants, its maximum weight and height limits might be reached relatively quickly, necessitating a transition to a larger car seat.
• Compatibility: Some users have reported that the KeyFit 30 might not fit as well in smaller or compact vehicles due to its size. It's recommended to check the car seat's compatibility with your vehicle before purchasing.

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

3. Britax One4Life ClickTightAll-in-One Car Seat

The Britax One4Life ClickTight All-in-One Car Seat is an exceptional guardian of your child's safety throughout their growth journey. With multiple layers of side-impact protection, a foolproof ClickTight installation system, premium padding, and an adjustable recline, this car seat commands a five-star rating for its unwavering commitment to providing the ultimate safety, comfort, and longevity.

Safety: Multiple layers of side-impact protection.

Installation: ClickTight system for foolproof installation.

Comfort: Premium padding, adjustable recline.

Performance: Ultimate longevity and safety. 

Pros:

• Extended use: The Britax One4Life is designed to accommodate your child's growth from infancy to toddlerhood and beyond. Its all-in-one design allows for rear-facing, forward-facing, and booster modes, providing exceptional value and convenience.
• User-friendly installation: The ClickTight installation system is praised for its simplicity and effectiveness. It makes securing the car seat in your vehicle a straightforward process, reducing the risk of improper installation.
• Safety features: With multiple layers of side-impact protection, adjustable harness heights, and a steel frame, theOne4Life prioritizes safety. The SecureGuard belt-positioning clip helps ensure proper lap belt placement in booster mode.

Cons:

• Bulky size: The One4Life's design, while accommodating, contributes to its larger size and weight. This might make it less ideal for smaller vehicles or those with limited space.
• Price point: The advanced features and extended use capabilities of the Britax One4Life are reflected in its price. It might be a higher initial investment compared to other car seats.
• Transition difficulties: Some parents have noted that transitioning between modes (e.g., from rear-facing to forward-facing) may require adjustments and rethreading of harness straps, which could be less convenient for busy parents. 

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

4. Nuna RAVA Convertible Car Seat

The Nuna RAVA Convertible Car Seat has a modern design and reliable safety features. With a robust steel frame, energy-absorbing foam, simple LATCH system, and luxurious features like plush padding and ventilated panels, it secures a four-star rating for its exceptional combination of safety and comfort for your child's road journeys.

Safety: Steel frame, energy-absorbing foam.

Installation: Simple LATCH system.

Comfort: Plush padding, ventilated panels.

Performance: Sleek design with top-notch safety. 

Pros:

• Advanced safety features: The Nuna RAVA hasfeatures like a robust steel frame and energy-absorbing foam. The side-impactprotection and advanced engineering enhance your child's protection in theevent of a collision.
• Ease of installation: The simple LATCH system and clear indicators make installing the Nuna RAVA a straightforward process, reducing the chances of installation errors and ensuring a secure fit.
• Comfort and design: With plush padding, adjustable recline, and ventilated panels, the Nuna RAVA prioritizes your child's comfort during car rides. It's sleek and stylish design is an added bonus for parents who appreciate aesthetics.

Cons:

• Price point: The Nuna RAVA's premium safety features and design are reflected in its price. It may be a more substantial investment compared to other convertible car seats on the market.
• Limited extended rear-facing: Some parents find that the Nuna RAVA's weight and height limits for rear-facing use might be outgrown by taller or heavier children earlier than desired.
• Bulkiness: The Nuna RAVA is relatively larger and heavier, which might pose challenges for families with smaller vehicles or those who need to switch the car seat between vehicles frequently.

OverallRating: ★★★★☆

‍

5. Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max ConvertibleCar Seat

The Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max Convertible Car Seat is a cozy haven of safety and convenience for your growing child. Featuring AirProtect technology, a deep recline, a quick-clip chest clip, and an extended weight range, this car seat earns a four-star rating for its focus on optimal protection and comfort, especially during extended rear-facing use.

Safety: Air Protect technology, deep recline.

Installation: QuickClip chest clip, LATCH connectors.

Comfort: Cosy fabric, extended weight range.

Performance: Ideal for extended rear-facing.

Pros:

• Advanced safety features: The Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max is equipped with Air Protect technology, providing additional protection in case of side-impact collisions. This feature enhances your child's safety during car rides.
• Extended rear-facing: With its high weight limit for rear-facing use, the Pria 85 Max allows your child to remain rear-facing for an extended period, which is recommended for optimal safety during their early years.
• Comfortable design: The car seat features plush padding and a deep recline, ensuring your child's comfort during longer journeys. The extended weight range accommodates larger children while maintaining a cozy environment. 

Cons:

• Bulkiness: The Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max is relatively larger and heavier, which might make it less suitable for smaller vehicles or for families needing to install multiple car seats.
• Limited extended use: While the Pria 85 Max accommodates rear-facing use for a longer duration, some parents may find that their child outgrows the seat's weight and height limits for forward-facing and booster modes sooner than expected.
• Price point: The advanced safety features and design of the Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max are reflected in its price. It might be a higher initial investment compared to other convertible car seats.

OverallRating: ★★★★☆

‍

6. Evenflo EveryStage DLX All-in-OneCar Seat

The Evenflo EveryStage DLX All-in-One Car Seat is versatile and evolves with your child's needs. With features like side-impact and rollover protection, SureSafe LATCH, and adjustable recline, this car seat earns a four-star rating for its adaptability, comfortable design, and commitment to safety throughout various stages of your child's journey.

Safety: Side-impact and rollover protection.

Installation: SureSafe LATCH, easy harness adjustments.

Comfort: Multiple recline positions, ample padding.

Performance: Adaptable for various ages.

Pros:

• Multi-stage versatility: The Evenflo EveryStage DLX is designed to accommodate your child from infancy to booster age, offering rear-facing, forward-facing, and booster modes. This versatility provides long-term value and eliminates the need for multiple car seats.
• Side-impact protection: The car seat features advanced side-impact protection, which is crucial for enhancing your child's safety in the event of a collision. Multiple layers of protection and energy-absorbing foam contribute to a higher level of security.
• Ease of installation: The SureSafe LATCH system and user-friendly features, such as easy harness adjustments and straightforward installation instructions, simplify the process of securing the car seat in your vehicle.

Cons:

• Bulkiness: The EveryStage DLX is relatively large and may take up significant space in your vehicle. This could be a concern, particularly for families with multiple car seats or smaller vehicles.
• Limited recline options: Some parents have noted that the car seat's recline options, especially in rear-facing mode, may not be as adjustable as desired, potentially affecting comfort for younger children.
• Strap twist issues: A few users have reported difficulties with the harness straps twisting, which could be a minor inconvenience during the installation process. 

OverallRating: ★★★★☆

‍

7. Diono Radian 3RXT All-in-OneConvertible Car Seat

The Diono Radian 3RXT All-in-One Convertible Car Seat offers a robust safety solution for your child's travel needs. With a reinforced steel frame, Safe+engineering, memory foam padding, and a space-efficient design, this car seat garners a five-star rating for its unwavering commitment to protection, comfort, and longevity. 

Safety: Reinforced steel frame, Safe+ engineering.

Installation: SuperLATCH system, narrow profile.

Comfort: Memory foam padding, adjustable headrest.

Performance: Space-efficient and long-lasting.

Pros:

• Enhanced safety: The Diono Radian 3RXT is known for its reinforced steel frame and Safe+ engineering, providing a high level of protection. The car seat also boasts memory foam padding for added comfort and security.
• Space-efficient design: The narrow profile of the Radian 3RXT allows for multiple car seats to fit side by side in the backseat, making it an excellent option for families with multiple children or vehicles with limited space.
• Extended use: With its high weight and height limits, the Radian 3RXT offers extended rear-facing, forward-facing, and booster modes, accommodating your child's growth and development over several years.

Cons:

• Weight and bulkiness: The steel-reinforced construction that contributes to the car seat's safety also adds to its weight and bulkiness, making it less convenient for parents who frequently move the seat between vehicles.
• Complex installation: Some parents may find the Radian 3RXT's installation process more intricate compared to other carseats, requiring careful attention to details like proper angle and tension.
• Harness adjustment: Adjusting the harness height might require rethreading, which could be less convenient and time-consuming compared to car seats with simpler harness adjustment mechanisms.

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

8. Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 LX Infant Car Seat

The Graco SnugRide SnugLock 35 LX Infant Car Seat provides secure and hassle-free protection for your smallest passenger. With crash-tested safety features, SnugLock technology, plush newborn insert, and an adjustable canopy, this car seat earns a five-star rating for its seamless installation and superior comfort tailored to your infant's needs.

Safety: Crash-tested, energy-absorbing foam.

Installation: SnugLock technology for secure fit.

Comfort: Plush newborn insert, adjustable canopy.

Performance: Hassle-free infant protection.

Pros:

• Easy installation: The SnugLock system simplifies the installation process, ensuring a secure fit with minimal effort.The one-hand adjustable handle and clear indicators make installation hassle-free for parents.
• Crash-tested safety: The car seat undergoes rigorous crash testing to meet safety standards, offering peace of mind to parents about their child's protection in the event of a collision.
• Comfort for infants: The car seat features a plush newborn insert and multiple recline positions, ensuring optimal comfort and support for your newborn during car rides. 

Cons:

• Limited longevity: As an infant car seat, theSnugRide SnugLock 35 LX has weight and height limits that your child may outgrow relatively quickly, necessitating a transition to a larger convertible car seat.
• Compatibility with strollers: While the carseat is compatible with Graco strollers, it may not be as universally compatible with other stroller brands, potentially limiting your options for creating a travel system.
• Size and weight: The SnugRide SnugLock 35 LXis relatively heavier compared to some other infant car seats, which might impact portability and ease of carrying, especially as your baby grows.

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

9. Clek Foonf Convertible Car Seat

The ClekFoonf Convertible Car Seat is a fortress of safety and design innovation. With a rigid LATCH system, energy-absorbing foam layers, Crypton fabric, and an adjustable headrest, this car seat commands a five-star rating for its exceptional blend of security, comfort, and sleek aesthetics that ensure a safe and stylish ride for your child. 

Safety: Rigid LATCH system, energy-absorbing foam layers.

Installation: Built like a tank, effortless installation.

Comfort: Crypton fabric, adjustable headrest.

Performance: Forward-facing excellence.

Pros:

• Top-notch safety: The Clek Foonf is renowned for its advanced safety features, including a rigid LATCH system and energy-absorbing foam layers. These elements contribute to a high level of protection in the event of a collision.
• Effortless installation: The built-like-a-tank construction of the Foonf doesn't compromise on ease of installation. Its straightforward LATCH system and clear indicators help ensure a secure fit in your vehicle.
• Sleek design: The car seat's sleek and modern design is appealing to parents who prioritize aesthetics, and the Crypton fabric is both stylish and resistant to stains and moisture.

Cons:

• Size and weight: The Foonf's solid construction and advanced safety features contribute to its weight and bulkiness, which might make it less suitable for smaller vehicles or frequent switching between vehicles.
• Price point: The premium safety features and design of the Clek Foonf are reflected in its price, making it a higher investment compared to other convertible car seats.
• Limited recline positions: Some parents have noted that the Foonf's range of recline positions may be more limited than desired, potentially affecting comfort for younger children, especially during long rides.

OverallRating: ★★★★★

‍

10. Cosco Scenera Next Convertible CarSeat

The Cosco Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat offers reliable protection without breaking the bank. With its lightweight design, simple belt path installation, cozy padding, and machine-washable fabric, this car seat secures a four-star rating for its budget-friendly approach to ensuring your child's safety and comfort on the road. 

Safety: Lightweight design, meets safety standards.

Installation: Simple belt path, easy installation.

Comfort: Cozy padding, machine-washable fabric.

Performance: Budget-friendly option without compromise. 

Pros:

• Affordability: The Cosco Scenera Next is budget-friendly, making it an excellent option for families seeking a cost-effective car seat without compromising basic safety features.
• Lightweight and portable: Its lightweight design and compact size make it a convenient choice for travel or switching between vehicles, especially for families on the go.
• Rear-facing for longer: The Cosco Scenera Next allows for extended rear-facing use, promoting optimal safety for your child during their early years.

Cons:

• Basic safety features: While the Cosco Scenera Next meets essential safety standards, it may not offer the same advanced safety features as higher-end car seats.
• Limited comfort features: The car seat may lack the plush padding and additional comfort elements found in more premium models, potentially affecting your child's comfort during longer rides.
• Shorter lifespan: Due to its budget-friendly nature, the Cosco Scenera Next may have lower weight and height limits compared to more expensive convertible car seats, potentially requiring a transition toa larger car seat sooner. 

OverallRating: ★★★★☆

‍

Comparison table - RateWorks car seat recommendations for 2023

Budget-friendly options

While safety remains the number one concern for parents, the financial aspect is also a pivotal consideration when selecting a car seat. Striking the balance between affordability and safety is crucial for families on a budget. Here are three top picks from our list that offer impressive safety features without breaking the bank: 

• Cosco Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat: A budget-friendly option that doesn't compromise on the basics of safety, making it ideal for families seeking an economical yet reliable car seat.
• Evenflo EveryStage DLX All-in-One Car Seat: Offering extended use and versatile modes, this car seat provides value for your investment, accommodating your child from infancy to booster age.
• Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 Max Convertible Car Seat: Balancing affordability with comfort and safety, this car seat features AirProtect technology for enhanced side-impact protection.

Making informed choices for your child’s safety

Knowledge empowers parents to make the best decisions for their child's safety and comfort. By considering the comprehensive evaluations and rankings provided in our RateWorks 10 Best CarSeats for 2023 article, you can confidently navigate the realm of car seats and choose the one that aligns with your family's needs.

 Whether it's the versatile Graco 4Ever DLX, the sleek Britax One4Life, or the budget-friendly Cosco Scenera Next, each seat on our list is a testament to our commitment to safety and reliable information. Prioritize your child's well-being on every journey – they deserve nothing less than the utmost care and protection on the road. For more important car safety tips and advice, be sure to read more on the RateWorks insights blog.